Late one evening in Seattle, I was staring at a latency spike on my local node while my partner complained about the 'over-engineered' router setup in the hallway closet. It is a familiar scene in our house—me trying to shave five milliseconds off a route to an East Coast server while she just wants the smart TV to stop buffering. After my employer disclosed that third-party data breach back in 2023, I stopped trusting 'default' security and started running my own speed comparisons across a dozen different VPN subscriptions.
This site uses affiliate links, which means I earn a commission if you pick up a subscription through them, though it comes at no extra cost to you. I have personally paid for and tested every service I talk about here—mostly because I am obsessed with grounded numbers and hate marketing fluff. You can read my full performance testing methodology here.
The 50-State Infrastructure Reality
Since late last year through the end of this summer, I have been leaning heavily into Private Internet Access (PIA). While most of the big-name players focus on having 'fast' servers in major hubs like New York or LA, PIA is the only one I have found that actually plants a flag in all 50 US states. For a dev who spends a lot of time testing regional routing bottlenecks, that is a huge deal. Around the holidays, I noticed my usual Seattle-to-Virginia routes were getting throttled by some upstream peering dispute. With PIA, I could just hop over to a server in a neighboring state and bypass the congestion entirely.
The scale here is almost absurd: they claim over 35,000+ servers globally. In practice, that density is a double-edged sword. While it means you are rarely fighting for bandwidth on a crowded node, it also introduces what I call the 'paradox of choice.' Most guides will tell you that more servers always equals better performance, but I have found that having too many options can actually degrade your experience if you are trying to manage effective load balancing across your own local network infrastructure. If you are piping your VPN through a home-rolled gateway, picking the 'wrong' one of 500 local options can sometimes lead to weird routing loops that a simpler network like NordVPN avoids by just giving you the best one automatically.
Open Source and Power User Tuning
On a rainy Saturday afternoon earlier this spring, I decided to get into the weeds with PIA’s desktop app. One thing I genuinely appreciate—and it appeals to the part of me that reads GitHub commits for fun—is that their apps are 100% open-source. I remember sitting there with my coffee, thinking, 'I could actually audit this code if I wanted to,' while knowing full well I would likely just check the latest commit message and go back to my drink. It is about the principle of transparency, especially when you are trusting a company with your entire packet stream.
Unlike some of the more 'Apple-fied' VPNs like ExpressVPN, PIA lets you mess with the internals. You can toggle between AES-256 and AES-128 encryption. If you are just trying to get decent speeds on a local Wi-Fi network that is already encrypted, dropping down to 128-bit can actually give you a noticeable throughput bump on older hardware. It is like choosing between a high-end cloud storage plan with all the bells and whistles or a raw S3 bucket where you control the lifecycle rules; one is easier, but the other lets you tune the engine.
I spent some time just before summer vacation testing their implementation of WireGuard. At roughly 4,000 lines of code, it is much easier to wrap your head around than the massive legacy of OpenVPN. In my testing from Seattle, I was hitting about 85% of my baseline fiber speed on most West Coast nodes. That is respectable, though I have seen Surfshark occasionally edge them out on raw downstream speed during off-peak hours.
What I Actually Noticed: Real World Usage
The sensory experience of using PIA is distinct. When I have the app open on my secondary monitor, there is this faint, consistent hum from the server rack in my closet—the physical manifestation of my 'over-engineered' life—while the PIA interface displays a dense sea of green ping markers across the US map. It is visually satisfying in a way that appeals to my need for data density. Late last month, I was testing some WSL2 configurations and found that PIA’s split tunneling is actually one of the more robust versions I’ve used, which is rare because split tunneling is notoriously flaky on Windows.
However, the UI is clearly built for people who know what an 'MTU' value is. If you just want a 'Protect Me' button, the sheer number of settings might feel like trying to configure a new enterprise-grade firewall when you just wanted to check your email. I’ve noticed that while the US network is massive, the streaming reliability can be hit-or-miss. Sometimes I’ll hit a server in Idaho that Netflix has already flagged, and I’ll have to cycle through a few others to find a 'clean' IP. If you are mostly looking for a 'set it and forget it' setup for the family, you might find more luck with a CyberGhost setup.
Final Thoughts on the Seattle-to-Everywhere Rig
For my specific needs—running a testing rig that requires granular control over which US state I am appearing from—Private Internet Access is hard to beat. The 50-state coverage isn't just a marketing bullet point; it is a functional tool for bypassing the weird, regional routing issues that plague US ISPs. It feels like the 'Power User Pick' for a reason. It doesn't hold your hand, and the massive server count requires a bit of manual steering to get the absolute best performance, but the transparency of the open-source apps makes the effort feel worth it.
If you are looking for a VPN that gives you the keys to the kingdom and doesn't hide the technical details behind a 'Simplified' UI, you should check out the latest plans at Private Internet Access. It has been a staple of my networking closet for the better part of a year, and despite my partner's eye-rolls at the 'sea of green' on my monitor, it is the one I trust when I need to see exactly where my data is going.